On 28 June 2005 the blessed speaking process began a left-catholic weekly paper explained by Johannes Paul II., why it is against the blessed speaking.

(kreuz.net) the left-catholic French weekly paper formulated seven main sins of the deceased of Pope Johannes Paul II. `Golias' in their editorial of the expenditure for the second day of death of the holy father in April.

First main sin

„The intellectual suppression “and „the institutional break “with theologians, bishops and medal people by Denunziation as well as by authoritarian and injuring intervening of the Glaubenskongregation.

Second main sin

The systematic resistance against „considering “the Sexualmoral in the light of the gospel, the human sciences and history.

Third main sin

Uncompromising holding to the Weltpriesterzölibat.


Fourth main sin

Missing control of dirty business in vatikanischen financing. That course-dug „the loaded “Personalprälatur `Opus Dei' - for `Golias' one „protects church in the church “- influential church positions.

Fifth main sin

The steady refusal of the deceased of Pope to really and discuss seriously the position of the woman in the church.

Sixth main sin

The continual denial of the principle of the Kollegialität with the line of the church.

Seventh main sin

The church and political isolation, which Johannes Paul II. would have brought and its to diplomat large church carriercarrier carriers such as archbishop OSCAR Romero († 1980) with their fight against the dictatorships - in El Salvador, Argentina, Guatemala, Chile, Nikaragua or Brazil -.

© frontispiece: Simone Donadello, Creative Commons

HeinrichderZweite: Dear T.S.,

but where it stands written that we are to run blindly by the world?

T.S.: Do humans determine?

I do not think it am right myself that humans determine the alleged death sins of others. We are not judges, but God…

Mathias Wagener: View that linking

That is the view of left circles, which cavort also in the church. Which was set up there at theses,
is opinion, which we take and as such good do not find to the knowledge.

Rudolfus: The seven „main sins “from view that God lots… however Johannes Paul as defenders of the faith?

These seven main sins in the eyes that God lots, these are naturally in reality seven catholic virtues as arguments for a blessed speaking of the Pope Johannes Paul II.

But if one regards the past Pontifikat as a quite creditor catholic 1978-2005 in its substantial office and personnel decisions, then there therein surely also positive is to see (like e.g. the many blessed and holy speaking), but the fundamental question for a blessed speaking Johannes Pauls II. would be:
Was Pope Johannes Paul II. a defender of the catholic faith?
And did it appoint defenders of the faith also as bishops and Cardinälen? (Cardinal Ratzinger owes his Cardinalskreierung Pope Paul VI.)

wickerl: bad Pädagogik

also Kreuznet confounds the dead sins with the main sins although it each other does not exclude. That was always a bad Pädagogik in the church.

Rudolfus: Johannes Pauls IITH zwiespältige Cardinalsernennungen as an important blessed speaking obstacle

Ever a Pope appointed as many Cardinäle as Johannes Paul II. - after since the reforms Johannes' XXIII. and Pauls VI. first of all the number of the Cardinäle on the one hand last expanded since the extremely high number of 120 Cardinälen was,
on the other hand however the über-80jährigen Cardinälen by Paul VI. the Papal election right was, and these among the 120 Papal election-entitled Cardinälen not to be ranked apparent at all, so that then over 120 Cardinäle would be:
Indeed the Pope-selecting 120 Cardinäle and the remaining emeritierten Cardinäle.

It is to be deplored anyhow much, how many Häretiker and modernists were taken up by Pope Johannes Paul II. in its extremely long highest church government to this highest papal Kollegium: An enormous mixture at theologian and bishops, who could more differently not be.

One may ask oneself by right, to appoint why Pope Johannes Paul II. did not let himself hold from it, official Häretiker into this highest Kollegium, as the most well-known example German häretischen and modernistic professor Walter Caspar, the former bishop v. gang castle Stuttgart (Federal state Baden-Wuerttemberg, FRG), and later Roman Kurienökumenismusbeauftragten!

While old catholic Austria at the end of the Johannes Paul II. - Term of office 1978-2005 only more a Pope-selecting Cardinal had: the archbishop Christian OF beautiful fount v. Vienna, a traditional Cardinalsstadt.